A song and its recording are two different copyrights: what the US Copyright Office says
A band that records its own song owns, or can own, two separate works. Who the author of a recording is, what the recording right covers and what happens before registration.
This article is general information drawn from a US Copyright Office circular, not legal advice. Copyright law differs between countries and the circular itself is an introduction. For a real dispute or a contract, ask a lawyer.
Two works, not one
The Copyright Office’s Circular 56 says a sound recording is generally a recorded performance, often of another work, and that it must be “fixed”, meaning captured in a form from which it can be perceived or reproduced, such as a digital track, a disc or a tape. It also says the copyright in a sound recording covers the recording itself and does not cover the music, lyrics or other content in it.
Its own example is a song written by two authors and a recording of someone else singing it: two distinct works. The underlying music and lyrics are a “musical work”, and a recording of a performance of the song is a “sound recording”.
For a band that writes and records its own song, that means there is a musical work (the song) and a sound recording (this particular recorded performance). The circular says registering a sound recording together with the song it contains is covered in a separate circular, 56A, and registering a song on its own in Circular 50. This article does not read those.
Who is the author of a recording
The circular says the author of a sound recording is the performer featured in the recording and the producer who captured and processed the sounds that appear in the final recording. If the performer or producer made the recording as part of their employment, it is a work made for hire and the employer is the author. If they made it for a third party as a contribution to a collective work and agreed in writing that it is a work made for hire, the third party is the author. The circular does not advise on ownership between band members; for that, ask a lawyer.
What protection starts when
Copyright in a recording made after 1 January 1978 arises on its own, the circular explains, at the moment the recording is first fixed. Neither registration nor publication is required for protection under the present law. A copyright notice was mandatory on published copies before 1 March 1989 and is optional for works published on or after that date.
What a recording owner can and cannot stop
Under the Copyright Act, as the circular puts it, a recording’s owner normally has no exclusive right of public performance, with one exception: performance by digital audio transmission. The right to perform a song publicly is a separate matter for the musical work, which this circular does not cover.
Easy confusions the circular clears up
| Term | What the circular says |
|---|---|
| Sound recording | The recorded performance, if fixed |
| Phonorecord | The physical or digital object that holds a recording, such as a CD, an LP or an .mp3 or .wav file |
| Soundtrack of a music video or concert video | Not a sound recording; the sounds accompanying an audiovisual work are part of that work |
| Mechanical changes such as a format change, declicking or noise reduction | Generally do not contain enough original authorship to warrant registration |
| A mashup or additional tracks added to a published album | A derivative sound recording, if the new material has a minimum of original sound recording authorship |
The circular gives concert-video soundtracks as an example of sounds that are part of an audiovisual work.
What this article does not say
It does not say whether to register, what registration costs, or how to split ownership between band members, and the circular gives no advice on any of those. It describes how the Office classifies the works.
Sources
- U.S. Copyright Office, Circular 56, Copyright Registration for Sound Recordings (revised March 2021): https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ56.pdf (opened 2026-11-02).